logo

Are Dolphins Really Smart?

TAGS:     

THEME:   NATURE

By SisiBroad | September 28, 2013 8:38 am

For more than 50 years, the dolphin has been viewed as an especially intelligent creature, grouped together with human beings and great apes. But now a dispute on the subject has erupted among scientists, and the smart aleck of the seas may end up being just an average mammal.

Lilly gushed, dolphins were "more intelligent than any man or woman."

Lilly gushed, dolphins were “more intelligent than any man or woman.”

“We put them on a pedestal for no reason and projected a lot of our desires and wishes on them,” says neuroethologist Paul Manger of the University of the Witwatersrand in South Africa. According to the professor, the claims that dolphins have a particularly complex brain, use a sophisticated language, are self-aware and can use tools are nonsense.

Physician and neuroscientist Dr. John Lilly

Physician and neuroscientist Dr. John Lilly

When goldfish are placed in a bowl, he explains, they at least try to escape by boldly jumping out, whereas dolphins that have been captured in nets won’t even think of jumping to freedom. Most dolphin researchers are offended by such remarks. “You can use similar arguments to prove that people aren’t intelligent,” says Karsten Brensing, a marine biologist with the organization Whale and Dolphin Conservation (WDC).

Notion of the intelligence of dolphin based on effort physician and neuroscientist John Lilly who played the crucial role in the elevation of dolphins from the status of fish to a human-like faculty of speech and attempted to establish contact with the marine mammals. His desire to communicate was so great he administered LSD to himself and the dolphins in the hopes of stimulating conversation.  Lilly gushed, dolphins were “more intelligent than any man or woman.” He even attributed them philosophy, ethics and an “ancient vocal history.”

Lilly’s legacy shapes our image of dolphins to this day.

A few arguments against dolphins’ outstanding brain.  Researchers were able to teach bottle-nosed dolphins 40 symbols, but African grey parrots and California sea lions can also learn this type of symbol-based language.

It is known that every dolphin can identify itself with its own “signature whistle,” but so does many other animals. It’s probably not the case that dolphins have their own language, which is as complex as human language,” says the expert in animal communication.

“We have to stop describing them as ‘special’,” says Gregg, a zoologist with the US-based Dolphin Communication Project.

It is becoming increasingly apparent that the marine mammals’ intellectual abilities are by no means unique in the animal kingdom. “Many other species-from sharks to earwigs to rats-lead equally wondrous and worthy lives,” he writes.

top_banner PRINT THIS

Comments are closed.

  • PLACE YOUR LISTINGS
  • RED LIGHT CAMERAS

  • MTA UPDATES

  • rek1
  • rek2
  • OUR WRITERS

    SokSok
    Jan OvlandJan Ovland
    Ann TyllerAnn Tyller
    SisiBroadSisiBroad
    Dan BartDan Bart
    Serge KSerge K
  • RSS Top News

    • Volatile weather situation for SW Virginia over next 2 days - Roanoke Times May 27, 2017
      Roanoke TimesVolatile weather situation for SW Virginia over next 2 daysRoanoke TimesOne HRRR short-range model depiction shows 3 clusters of storms -- one that has moved past to near the coast, one having moved just past Roanoke, and a larger one to the west -- late this evening. The exact location and timing of storms […]
    • 2 fatally stabbed on Oregon train after trying to stop man's anti-Muslim rants, police say - Washington Post May 27, 2017
      Washington Post2 fatally stabbed on Oregon train after trying to stop man's anti-Muslim rants, police sayWashington PostTwo men were stabbed to death Friday on a light-rail train in Portland, Ore., after they tried to intervene when another passenger began “ranting and raving” and shouting anti-Muslim hate speech at two young women, police said. According to […]
    • Trump adviser: 'I would not be concerned' about a Russia back channel, irrespective of Kushner - Washington Post May 27, 2017
      Washington PostTrump adviser: 'I would not be concerned' about a Russia back channel, irrespective of KushnerWashington PostTAORMINA, Italy -- President Trump's National Security Adviser H.R. McMaster said Saturday he "would not be concerned" about having a back-channel communications system with Russia, though he and other top White House officials refused to comment ...Two top Trump advisers […]
    • The Latest: France's Macron urges Trump: Stay in Paris pact - Washington Post May 27, 2017
      Washington PostThe Latest: France's Macron urges Trump: Stay in Paris pactWashington PostTAORMINA, Sicily — The Latest on Group of Seven summit (all times local):. 5:10 p.m.. After a two-day summit in Italy, French President Emmanuel Macron had warm words for Donald Trump, despite the fact the U.S. president did not join in with other ...Leaders […]
    • The Manchester Bombing and Why the Battle Against ISIS Won't End With Iraq and Syria - Newsweek May 27, 2017
      NewsweekThe Manchester Bombing and Why the Battle Against ISIS Won't End With Iraq and SyriaNewsweekOrlando, Nice, Paris, Brussels, Berlin, Würzburg, Ansbach, Munich, London—and now Manchester. The pattern is becoming depressingly familiar. The news breaks with blurry cellphone footage—pedestrians strolling on a seaside promenade, shoppers ...Britain's Terror Threat Level Reduced to 'Severe' After Raids Linked to Manchester […]
  • RSS NYC Latest News


  •