logo

NY Judge Sides With Apple: Feds Can’t Force Apple To Unlock An IPhone

TAGS:     , ,

THEME:   LIFE STYLE, NATION, WORLD

By Dan Bart | February 29, 2016 9:44 pm

A US magistrate judge in New York has ruled that the government can’t force Apple to help law enforcement unlock an iPhone using the All Writs Act. This case in question is about drug trafficking and is not related to the San Bernardino shooter case.

Magistrate Judge James Orenstein states: “More specifically, the established rules for interpreting a statute’s text constrain me to reject the government’s interpretation that the AWA empowers a court to grant any relief not outright prohibited by law.”

The judge’s ruling in the New York case rested on another Apple-friendly premise: the notion that what the government wants “is unavailable because Congress has considered legislation that would achieve the same result but has not adopted it.”

A US magistrate judge in New York has ruled that the government can't force Apple to help law enforcement unlock an iPhone using the All Writs Act

A US magistrate judge in New York has ruled that the government can’t force Apple to help law enforcement unlock an iPhone using the All Writs Act

Judge Orenstein ruled that this is an issue that should be handled by Congress. If the government wants to use All Writs or CALEA to force companies to circumvent encryption, there needs to a clear law granting it that power.

On top of this, Apple senior executive claimed that Apple has never created or signed any piece of software to decrypt their phone.

Apple general counsel Bruce Sewell said the public should understand that “encryption is a good thing, a necessary thing” even if it makes the work of law enforcement more difficult.

Sewell stressed that Apple has been stepping up its encryption over the past few years.

“As attacks on our customers’ data become increasingly sophisticated, the tools we use to defend against them must get stronger too,” he said.

“Weakening encryption will only hurt consumers and other well-meaning users who rely on companies like Apple to protect their personal information.”

Encryption helps preserve privacy around the world, he added, “and it keeps people safe.”

top_banner PRINT THIS

Comments are closed.

  • PLACE YOUR LISTINGS
  • RED LIGHT CAMERAS

  • MTA UPDATES

  • rek1
  • rek2
  • OUR WRITERS

    SokSok
    Jan OvlandJan Ovland
    Ann TyllerAnn Tyller
    SisiBroadSisiBroad
    Dan BartDan Bart
    Serge KSerge K
  • RSS Top News

    • The Latest: McMaster: N. Korea a 'grave threat' to US, China - Washington Post April 30, 2017
      Washington PostThe Latest: McMaster: N. Korea a 'grave threat' to US, ChinaWashington PostSEOUL, South Korea — The Latest on North Korea test-firing a missile (all times local):. 10:10 p.m.. Trump's national security adviser, Army Lt. Gen. H.R. McMaster, says North Korea's most recent missile test represents “open defiance of the ...S.Korea says US reaffirms it […]
    • Hasan Minhaj's Trump-bashing comedy routine at the White House correspondents' dinner, annotated - Washington Post April 30, 2017
      Washington PostHasan Minhaj's Trump-bashing comedy routine at the White House correspondents' dinner, annotatedWashington PostPresident Trump did not attend the White House correspondents' dinner, but he was still the butt of host Hasan Minhaj's jokes. We have annotated Minhaj's remarks using Genius. To see an annotation, click on the yellow, highlighted text. Thank you ...For Journalists, […]
    • Wild storms bring death, destruction from Texas to Missouri - USA TODAY April 30, 2017
      USA TODAYWild storms bring death, destruction from Texas to MissouriUSA TODAYFlash flood warnings were issued in multiple states Sunday, hours after tornadoes, heavy storms and floods roared through the Midwest from Missouri to Texas, leaving a trail of death and destruction. Five people were feared dead and dozens more injured ...WDAM via CNNLocal 10Official: Deaths reported, […]
    • Doug Whaley fired as Bills general manager - ESPN April 30, 2017
      ESPNDoug Whaley fired as Bills general managerESPNORCHARD PARK, N.Y. -- The Buffalo Bills fired general manager Doug Whaley, the team announced Sunday. The Bills were 30-34 in Whaley's four seasons as general manager. His only winning season came in 2014, when the Bills finished 9-7 but missed ...Doug Whaley Fired by Bills, Owner Terry Pegula Releases […]
    • The Latest: US won't seek South Korean money for THAAD - New York Daily News April 30, 2017
      New York Daily NewsThe Latest: US won't seek South Korean money for THAADNew York Daily NewsA South Korean protester holds up a card during a rally to oppose a plan to deploy the advanced U.S. missile defense system called Terminal High-Altitude Area Defense, or THAAD, near U.S. Embassy in Seoul, South Korea, Saturday, April 29, […]
  • RSS NYC Latest News


  •