logo

NY Judge Sides With Apple: Feds Can’t Force Apple To Unlock An IPhone

TAGS:     , ,

THEME:   LIFE STYLE, NATION, WORLD

By Dan Bart | February 29, 2016 9:44 pm

A US magistrate judge in New York has ruled that the government can’t force Apple to help law enforcement unlock an iPhone using the All Writs Act. This case in question is about drug trafficking and is not related to the San Bernardino shooter case.

Magistrate Judge James Orenstein states: “More specifically, the established rules for interpreting a statute’s text constrain me to reject the government’s interpretation that the AWA empowers a court to grant any relief not outright prohibited by law.”

The judge’s ruling in the New York case rested on another Apple-friendly premise: the notion that what the government wants “is unavailable because Congress has considered legislation that would achieve the same result but has not adopted it.”

A US magistrate judge in New York has ruled that the government can't force Apple to help law enforcement unlock an iPhone using the All Writs Act

A US magistrate judge in New York has ruled that the government can’t force Apple to help law enforcement unlock an iPhone using the All Writs Act

Judge Orenstein ruled that this is an issue that should be handled by Congress. If the government wants to use All Writs or CALEA to force companies to circumvent encryption, there needs to a clear law granting it that power.

On top of this, Apple senior executive claimed that Apple has never created or signed any piece of software to decrypt their phone.

Apple general counsel Bruce Sewell said the public should understand that “encryption is a good thing, a necessary thing” even if it makes the work of law enforcement more difficult.

Sewell stressed that Apple has been stepping up its encryption over the past few years.

“As attacks on our customers’ data become increasingly sophisticated, the tools we use to defend against them must get stronger too,” he said.

“Weakening encryption will only hurt consumers and other well-meaning users who rely on companies like Apple to protect their personal information.”

Encryption helps preserve privacy around the world, he added, “and it keeps people safe.”

top_banner PRINT THIS

Comments are closed.

  • PLACE YOUR LISTINGS
  • RED LIGHT CAMERAS

  • MTA UPDATES

  • rek1
  • rek2
  • OUR WRITERS

    SokSok
    Jan OvlandJan Ovland
    Ann TyllerAnn Tyller
    SisiBroadSisiBroad
    Dan BartDan Bart
    Serge KSerge K
  • RSS Top News

    • Hurricane Maria and Puerto Rico's Neo-Colonial Legacy - The New Yorker October 18, 2017
      The New YorkerHurricane Maria and Puerto Rico's Neo-Colonial LegacyThe New YorkerTwo of the Spanish-American War's last battles were fought near Aibonito, Puerto Rico, on land now owned by Ramón Rivera. Photograph by Christopher Gregory for The New Yorker. The view southward from the Asomante hills outside the Puerto Rican ...FEMA Chief Blamed for Katrina Response Says […]
    • Police: A surviving victim of Maryland gunman knows suspect - CNN October 18, 2017
      CNNPolice: A surviving victim of Maryland gunman knows suspectCNN(CNN) A gunman who authorities say killed three people and wounded two others at his job in Maryland early Wednesday shot a sixth person at a Wilmington, Delaware, car dealership hours later, officials said. Radee Labeeb Prince, 37, shot the male ...Three killed in shooting at a […]
    • Las Vegas guard Jesus Campos tells Ellen DeGeneres: 'I felt a burning sensation' when I was shot - Fox News October 18, 2017
      Fox NewsLas Vegas guard Jesus Campos tells Ellen DeGeneres: 'I felt a burning sensation' when I was shotFox NewsMandalay Bay security guard Jesus Campos and engineer Stephen Schuck spoke to 'The Ellen DeGeneres Show' in an interview that aired Wednesday. (Michael Rozman/Warner Bros./Handout via REUTERS). The Mandalay Bay security guard who briefly ...Las Vegas shooting survivor, […]
    • Obama's Name to Replace Jefferson Davis' on Mississippi School - NBCNews.com October 18, 2017
      NBCNews.comObama's Name to Replace Jefferson Davis' on Mississippi SchoolNBCNews.comA public elementary school in Mississippi named after the president of the Confederacy will be renamed to honor the first black president of the United States. Davis Magnet International Baccalaureate Elementary, which is named for Jefferson Davis ...Mississippi School Named After Jefferson Davis to be Renamed After […]
    • Trump offered a grieving military father $25000 in a call, but didn't follow through - Washington Post October 18, 2017
      Washington PostTrump offered a grieving military father $25000 in a call, but didn't follow throughWashington PostPresident Trump, in a personal phone call to a grieving military father, offered him $25,000 and said he would direct his staff to establish an online fundraiser for the family, but neither happened, the father said. Chris Baldridge, the father […]
  • RSS NYC Latest News


  •