What is better for us Moon or Mars?



By Ann Tyller | June 10, 2016 11:56 pm

Congress ready to shift space priorities.

With the end of Obama’s presidency the idea of a return trip to the moon is getting more popular and Congress is reconsidering the national’s space priorities.

Prioritizing the moon over the asteroid program would represent a major shift in NASA’s priorities.

Prioritizing the moon over the asteroid program would represent a major shift in NASA's priorities.

Prioritizing the moon over the asteroid program would represent a major shift in NASA’s priorities.

The present administration’s space policy has long favored an asteroid mission

During the appropriations process, the House instructed NASA to cease the asteroid mission and instead “develop plans to return to the Moon to test capabilities that will be needed for Mars, including habitation modules, lunar prospecting, and landing and ascent vehicles.”

“There is no better proving ground than the Moon for NASA to test the technologies and techniques needed to successfully meet the goal of sending humans to Mars by the mid 2030s,” said Rep. Mike Honda (D) of Calif.

NASA says the asteroid mission will give them experience in human spaceflight beyond low-Earth orbit and allow them to test technologies that would be necessary in a Mars mission. NASA said a human mission to Mars could help address the question of whether life exists beyond Earth.

“Mars is a rich destination for scientific discovery and robotic and human exploration as we expand our presence into the solar system,” NASA said on its website. “Its formation and evolution are comparable to Earth, helping us learn more about our own planet’s history and future.”

Prioritizing a return trip to the moon before the trip to Mars has gained popularity in recent years. In an op-ed for Space.com, Leroy Chiao, a former NASA astronaut and ISS commander, wrote that the Apollo program is now a distant memory and a return trip to the moon is necessary before a mission to Mars.

“What we really need is a new generation of explorers who can handle the moon, before biting off the enormous costs and risks of sending people to Mars,” Dr. Chiao wrote.

Dr. Chiao wrote the asteroid retrieval mission is “somewhat vague” and interest in the mission is “tepid at best.” The technology that NASA would test in the asteroid mission could more easily be tested in a trip to the moon, he wrote. Once a spacecraft performs a trans-Mars injection burn, there will not be enough fuel to turn around if the hardware fails, so it is essential to make sure it works.

“Where better to test this hardware, off-Earth, than the nearby moon (three days away)?” he wrote. “We would wring out the hardware, develop operations and train crew. Then, we would be ready to mount an astronaut mission to Mars.”

top_banner PRINT THIS

Comments are closed.



  • rek1
  • rek2

    Jan OvlandJan Ovland
    Ann TyllerAnn Tyller
    Dan BartDan Bart
    Serge KSerge K
  • RSS Top News

    • Bipartisan senators reach small deal on health care - CNN October 17, 2017
      CNNBipartisan senators reach small deal on health careCNN(CNN) Sens. Lamar Alexander and Patty Murray have reached a deal "in principle" to restore Affordable Care Act cost-sharing reduction payments for two years in exchange for more state flexibility in Obamacare. One Senate aide said the plan would also ...Key senators reach bipartisan health-care subsidy deal, and Trump […]
    • Trump takes credit for ISIS 'giving up' - CNN October 17, 2017
      CNNTrump takes credit for ISIS 'giving up'CNNWashington (CNN) President Donald Trump took credit for the fact that ISIS is in retreat during an interview Tuesday, claiming that ISIS wasn't on the run before because "you didn't have Trump as your president." The comment comes as US-backed forces ...Raqqa, ISIS 'Capital,' Is Captured, US-Backed Forces SayNew York […]
    • Mystery as Vegas police stop news conferences on massacre, call wounded guard a 'victim' - Fox News October 17, 2017
      Fox NewsMystery as Vegas police stop news conferences on massacre, call wounded guard a 'victim'Fox NewsThe Mandalay Bay Resort and Casino security guard who was shot during the Las Vegas massacre has gone into hiding. Jesus Campos was scheduled to share his story in TV interviews last week, but canceled his appearances at the last […]
    • Federal judge blocks Trump's third travel ban - Washington Post October 17, 2017
      Washington PostFederal judge blocks Trump's third travel banWashington PostA federal judge on Tuesday largely blocked the Trump administration from implementing the latest version of the president's controversial travel ban, setting up yet another legal showdown on the extent of the executive branch's powers when it comes to ...Hawaii judge blocks Trump's latest travel banCNNJudge blocks Trump's […]
    • Carter Page subpoenaed by Senate intel committee - CNN October 17, 2017
      CNNCarter Page subpoenaed by Senate intel committeeCNN(CNN) The Senate intelligence committee has issued a subpoena to former Donald Trump foreign policy adviser Carter Page, according to a source familiar with the matter. The subpoena was issued after Page told the committee last week he would plead the ...Senate Presses Ex-Trump Aide's Son for Documents in Russia […]
  • RSS NYC Latest News